Goodyear vs Pirelli Tires: A Head to Head Comparison


If you are looking for tires for your vehicle, then the names Goodyear and Pirelli will be on the top of your shopping list. However which one of these tire brands is better?

Goodyear and Pirelli serve very different drivers. If you drive a high-performance or luxury vehicle, then Pirelli tires are the best choice. However, if you are looking for good value for a safe set of tires for your family vehicle, then Goodyear tires will be best.

In this head-to-head comparison, we’ll compare both Goodyear and Pirelli tires in a number of different categories including variety, performance, off-road capability, wet weather handling, value, longevity, and warranty.

Brake pads

About Goodyear

Goodyear is one of the biggest names in tires. While the company offers all types of tires, the company is renowned for its focus on safety as well as value. Chances are, if you are looking for tires for a family vehicle such as a sedan, SUV, or minivan, then Goodyear tires will be on the top of your list.

About Pirelli

If you are a fan of motorsport, then you are familiar with the Pirelli name. Pirelli is one of the top makers of sports and performance-oriented tires. Yes, Pirelli does make “everyday” tires for your typical family sedan or SUV. However, the company makes its reputation known for creating tires that add a high level of performance and control for the world’s fastest and more powerful vehicles.

Variety

Starting off with Goodyear, you will find a wide variety of vehicles in its lineup. You can find a wide variety of summer, all-season, performance, off-road, run-flat, and winter tires. Also, you will find Goodyear tires in a variety of sizes to fit all types of vehicles from cars to trucks and SUVs.

Pirelli also offers a wide variety of tires. However, its lineup of tires is arranged by “family” rather than traditional categories such as summer, winter, all-season, etc. With Pirelli, you’ll find tires in the P Zero, Cinturaro, Scorpion, Sottozero, and Ice Family family. Each of these tires serves a specific specialty and capability such as performance, all-weather capability, or winter driving capability.

Overall, when it comes to the sheer variety of tires, Goodyear gives you more to choose from.

Performance Tires

There is really no debate here. While Goodyear does offer its own selection of performance tires with its Eagle lineup, Pirelli is arguably the most well-respected name in performance. Pirelli’s line of P Zero tires is used on some of the most powerful luxury, ultra-luxury, and exotic vehicles on the planet. If you are serious about your vehicle’s performance, then there is only one choice. Pirelli wins when it comes to performance.

Offroad/All-Terrain Tires

Whether you have a truck or you just want tires that can handle the roughest weather, you will certainly find more choices and better choices when it comes to Goodyear. The brand offers its line of Wrangler all-terrain tires which are a popular choice for many off-road enthusiasts. Pirelli offers its line-up of off-road tires with its Scorpion family of tires. While these tires are a great choice, they don’t quite have the reputation nor the popularity of Goodyear’s Wrangler line of tires. Goodyear wins in this category.

Wet weather handling

You will not go wrong with wet weather handling whether you are looking at Goodyear or Pirelli tires. It really comes down to what type of vehicle that you are driving. If you are driving a more conventional vehicle, then Goodyear can offer you a number of excellent choices. However, if you are taking a high-performance vehicle on a wet road, then you will want to grab a set of Pirelli tires. On the Goodyear site, you will want to check out the Goodyear Wrangler Territory tires which are available for a wide variety of vehicles. On the Pirelli side, consider the Scorpion Verde All-Season tires. When it comes to wet weather handling, it’s a tie between both Goodyear and Pirelli.

Goodyear tire shop

Value

When it comes to value, the clear-cut winner is Goodyear. The company offers the best bang for your buck no matter what type of tire that you are considering. Even if you are looking for performance tires on a budget, you will find better choices from Goodyear including its lineup of Eagle performance tires. Pirelli is more of a premium brand. While Pirelli tires are excellent overall, you are paying a premium for the brand name. The winner here goes to Goodyear.

Longevity

When it comes to a tire that will last, you will find some excellent choices with both Goodyear and Pirelli. With Goodyear, you can get the Goodyear Assurance Maxlife tires that come with a  tread life guarantee of 85,000 miles. With Pirelli, you can get a Pirelli P4 All Season Tires which have a tire life warranty of 90,000 miles. With a slightly higher tire life warranty, the edge here goes to Pirelli.

Warranty

Goodyear offers three types of warranties for their tires. All tires come with a tread life warranty that will vary by tire model. Second, each tire comes with the Goodyear Highway Auto & Light Truck Tire Replacement Limited Warranty. This is a “defect” warranty that covers tires if there is a problem due to its manufacturing. Finally, all Goodyear tires have a 30-day return policy with certain restrictions.

Pirelli tires come with three types of warranties as well. First, there is a tread life warranty that will vary by tire model. Also, all Pirelli tires have a limited warranty that will cover defects on the tread or sidewall. Finally, Pirelli tires come with a 30-day money-back guarantee with some restrictions. However, it should be said that Pirelli does offer a number of conditions for your tire to qualify for the tread life warranty. For instance, you will have to show proof that you had your tires rotated every 6,000 to 8,000 miles.

Overall, both companies offer excellent warranty programs. However, Goodyear gets the edge for being less restrictive.

No matter which brand you choose, be sure to carefully check the features on each tire before making your final purchasing decision.

Check out the Amazon link below for cracking hot deals on tires conveniently delivered to your door.

Amazon Tires

You may find the following posts useful:

Are cheap tires worth it?

Should I buy tires at Wal-Mart?

Goodyear vs Bridgestone

Is Shell gas better?

John Cunningham

John Cunningham is an Automotive Technician and writer on Rustyautos.com. I've been a mechanic for over twenty-five years, and I've worked for GM, Volvo, Volkswagen, Landrover, and Jaguar dealerships. My passion is cars. I use my knowledge and experience to write articles that help fellow gear-heads with all aspects of car ownership, including buying advice, maintenance, and troubleshooting.

Recent Posts