Goodyear vs BF Goodrich Tires: Which Brand is Better?


If you are tire shopping, then you may be familiar with the Goodyear and the BF Goodrich tire brands. So which one of these brands is going to be best for your vehicle?

If you are looking for a long-lasting, value-priced, safe tire for your family vehicle, then a Goodyear tire is going to be your best choice. If you have a truck or an SUV that you want to use for rugged driving conditions, then you are going to find more suitable choices from BF Goodrich.

In this post, we’ll take a look at both brands of tires in a series of different categories.

BF Goodrich tires

About Goodyear

Goodyear is perhaps one of the best-known names in tires. The company has been in existence for over a century and provides a wide range of tires for all types of vehicles. Goodyear is really known for two things: value and safety. If you are looking to equip your family sedan or SUV with a pair of quality tires for less then you will want to start your search with Goodyear.

About BF Goodrich

BF Goodrich is another big name in the world of tires. You will find a wide range of tires from BF Goodrich including performance, offroad, passenger, and UTV tires. If there is one thing that BF Goodrich is known for it is their offroad tire and all-season tire collection. If you like to drive off-road or if you want a set of durable tires for your truck, then you will want to start off your search with BF Goodrich tires.

Variety

When it comes to variety, it is hard to beat Goodyear. You will find a wide selection of winter, summer, all-season, performance, and off-road tires. Within each of these categories, you will find subbrands from Goodyear including the Eagle performance tires, the Wrangler off-road/all-terrain tires, and the Assurance line of all-season tires.

BF Goodrich gives you a wide range of tires. The tire maker separates their tire inventory into four categories: Performance, passenger, light truck, and UTV vehicles. The company offers five families of tires across their inventory including Advantage all-season tires, commercial truck tires, G Force performance tires, mud tires, and radial tires.

Overall, both Goodyear and BF Goodrich offer a wide variety of tires. In this category, we’d have to call it a draw.

Performance Tires

Both Goodyear and BF Goodrich offers their own line of performance tires. Goodyear has its well-regarded line of Eagle performance tires that have been around for decades. BF Goodrich offers its G Force line of performance tires. Both of these subbrand of tires off a number of different selections. However, Goodyear’s Eagle subbrand has more top tire selections and a better reputation among performance vehicle drivers. The win here goes to Goodyear.

Offroad/All-Terrain Tires

When it comes to offroad and all-terrain tires, you will find lots to choose from between Goodyear and BF Goodwrench. Goodyear has a lineup of Wrangler off-road and all-terrain tires that are ideal for SUVs and trucks. BF Goodrich offers their lineup of advantage tires as well as a line-up of mud tires. When it comes to a variety of off-road and all-terrain tires, BF Goodrich is the clear winner. They will give you more options for extreme off-road driving. The win here goes to BF Goodrich.

Wet weather handling

Goodyear is known for creating some of the best vehicles for rough driving conditions. Some of the best-wet weather tires from Goodyear include the Assurance WeatherReady tire. This tire is especially excellent when it comes to snow, slush, and icy road conditions. The top wet weather tire from BF Goodrich includes the Advantage T/A Sport tire. This tire is designed to provide excellent grip in mud and snow. While both tire makers make excellent wet weather tires, the reputation of the Assurance WeatherReady tire is one of the best in the category. Goodyear gets the win here.

Value

When it comes to value, it is always going to be hard to beat Goodyear. The company has made a reputation for providing some of the best tires for the price. BF Goodrich has some great tires. However, the tire maker is not really known for providing lots of value from their tire selection. The clear winner here belongs to Goodyear.

Longevity

Goodyear is known for having some excellent tires that are designed to last. The Goodyear tire with the longest tread life guarantee is the Goodyear Assurance Maxlife. This tire comes with an 85,000-mile limited tread life warranty. BF Goodrich offers its Advantage T/A Sport LT tire with a 65,000-mile warranty. Overall, Goodyear is going to be your choice with it comes to long-lasting tires.

Warranty

Goodyear offers three types of warranties for all of its tires. All tires come with a tread life warranty. The length of the warranty will vary by the tire model. Second, each tire comes with the Goodyear Highway Auto & Light Truck Tire Replacement Limited Warranty. This warranty will cover any defects on the tire. Finally, each Goodyear tire comes with a 30-day conditional return policy.

All BF Goodrich tires come with a Standard Manufacture Warranty that will cover the product for any defects. The warranty is good for six years from the purchase date of the tire. Also, each tire comes with a tread life warranty that will vary by the tire model. Finally, all BF Goodrich tires come with a 60-day return policy.

Overall, both tire brands offer excellent warranty packages. However, BF Goodrich’s 60-day return policy gives it the win here.

Goodyear Vs. BF Goodrich Tires: The Bottom line

Overall both Goodyear and BF Goodrich offer a wide variety of tires. However, the best tire for your vehicle is really going to depend on how you use the vehicle.

No matter which tires you choose, be sure to carefully check out the tire’s features and the customer reviews before making that final purchasing decision.

Check out the Amazon link below for tires conveniently delivered to your door.

Amazon Car Tires

You may find these posts useful also:

Are cheap tires worth it?

Goodyear vs Pirelli

Should I buy tires at Walmart?

Goodyear vs Bridgestone

Is Shell gas better?

John Cunningham

John Cunningham is an Automotive Technician and writer on Rustyautos.com. I've been a mechanic for over twenty-five years, and I've worked for GM, Volvo, Volkswagen, Landrover, and Jaguar dealerships. My passion is cars. I use my knowledge and experience to write articles that help fellow gear-heads with all aspects of car ownership, including buying advice, maintenance, and troubleshooting.

Recent Posts