Hearing strange noises or experiencing frustrating, intermittent starting issues? A faulty starter motor can manifest in various ways, from complete silence when you turn the key to alarming grinding noises under the hood.
But before we assume the worst, let’s rule out a more common culprit: the battery. A flat or faulty battery can often be the root cause of starting problems. Many modern cars won’t attempt to engage the starter motor if the voltage is too low.
So, before exploring the signs of a bad starter motor, ensure our battery is fully charged, and the terminals are clean and securely connected.
In this guide, we’ll walk you through the most common signs of a failing starter motor, explain why these issues happen, and offer quick tips to help you diagnose the problem. Whether you’re a seasoned DIY mechanic or trying to avoid a trip to the shop, this guide will give you the knowledge you need to get your car back on the road.
Let’s get started!
Table of Contents
- Engine Doesn’t Crank
- Click Sound
- Intermittent Starting Issues
- Grinding Noise
- Smoke or Burning Smell
- Other Possible Causes
Engine Doesn’t Crank
When you turn the key or push the start button, nothing happens—no engine noise or cranking—your starter motor could be the issue. This is the most obvious sign that something is wrong.
If the engine doesn’t crank, it could mean that the starter motor has completely failed, or there might be an issue with the electrical connections leading to it.
Why It Happens:
The starter motor is responsible for physically turning the engine over to start it. If it’s not cranking, the motor itself may have failed due to wear and tear, or there could be a problem with the wiring, such as corroded or loose connections, preventing the necessary power from reaching the starter.
Quick Tip:
Let’s check our connections before we assume the starter motor is toast. Ensure the battery terminals are clean, tight, and corrosion-free. Also, check the wiring at the starter motor solenoid.
Single Click Sound
If you hear a single, solid click when you turn the key or push the start button, but the engine doesn’t turn over, it’s a strong indicator of a starter motor issue. This sound is typically the result of the starter solenoid failure.
Why It Happens:
The starter solenoid is an electrical component built into the starter motor that controls battery power flow to the motor. When you turn the key, the solenoid activates, allowing electricity to reach the starter motor. If the solenoid is faulty, you’ll hear a single click sound, but the engine won’t crank.
Although a faulty starter motor can also cause unusual noises, the issue is often due to the solenoid itself. While the solenoid is integrated with the starter motor, in many cases, it can be replaced separately without replacing the entire starter motor.
Quick Tip:
If you hear a single click and the engine doesn’t start, tap the starter motor with a hammer while someone else turns the key. This can sometimes help the motor engage. This is a temporary fix, and the solenoid will need to be replaced.
Pro Tip:
A weak battery can also cause a single click sound with no engine turnover; however, a flat battery is more closely associated with several audible clicks when the ignition is engaged.
If you suspect a flat battery or want to eliminate it as a possible issue, hook up a donor vehicle and attempt to jumpstart it.
If it still refuses to crank, focus on the starter motor.
You may find the following links helpful:
How to identify positive battery post
How to check battery voltage and test battery
Intermittent Starting Issues
Intermittent starting issues can be incredibly frustrating. Sometimes, your car starts without a hitch; other times, it refuses to turn over. This inconsistency often indicates a failing starter motor, which may have trouble engaging or receiving the proper electrical signals.
Why It Happens:
A starter motor that works intermittently is often a sign of internal wear and tear. The motor might be sticking, or there could be an issue with the electrical connections that worsens over time. Environmental factors like cold weather can also exacerbate the problem, making it harder for the starter motor to engage when temperatures drop. Moisture can cause electrical contacts to corrode, further contributing to the issue.
Quick Tip:
Track when the starting issues occur. Is it more common in the morning, after the car sits, or when it’s icy outside? Noting these patterns can help you or your mechanic diagnose whether the starter motor is the root cause or if another issue, like a weak battery or bad wiring, is to blame.
Pro Tip:
If your car starts fine after you’ve driven it for a while but struggles to start after sitting overnight, the problem might be related to the starter motor or battery. In this case, testing the starter and battery in both cold and warm conditions can help pinpoint the issue.
Grinding Noise
If you hear a grinding noise when you try to start your car, it’s a sign that the starter motor is not engaging properly with the flywheel or flexplate. This noise can be alarming and is often caused by worn-out gears within the starter motor or a misalignment between the starter gear and the flywheel.
Why It Happens:
The starter motor has a small gear (known as the pinion gear) that meshes with the larger gear on the flywheel to turn the engine over. If the pinion gear is worn out, damaged, or not aligning correctly, it will grind against the flywheel instead of smoothly engaging.
This grinding noise indicates that the starter motor is struggling to do its job, and if left unchecked, it can cause serious damage to the flywheel or flexplate, which is much more expensive to repair or replace.
Quick Tip:
If you hear grinding, stop trying to start the engine immediately to avoid further damage. It’s best to have the starter motor inspected and replaced if necessary. Additionally, have the flywheel or flexplate checked for any signs of damage.
Smoke or Burning Smell
This is a serious warning sign if you notice smoke or a burning smell coming from the area around the starter motor. These symptoms typically indicate that the starter motor is overheating or experiencing internal failure.
Why It Happens:
Smoke or a burning smell is usually caused by excessive current draw or internal components overheating within the starter motor. This can occur if the starter motor is faulty, draws more power than intended, or has an issue with the wiring that causes a short circuit or excessive resistance.
Overheating can damage the starter motor beyond repair and potentially lead to other electrical problems in your vehicle.
Quick Tip:
If you detect smoke or a burning smell, stop using the starter motor immediately to prevent further damage. Allow the motor to cool down, and then have it inspected by a professional as soon as possible.
Pro Tip:
After replacing a faulty starter motor, check the condition of the wiring relay and connections to ensure they are not damaged or corroded. Proper maintenance of these components can help prevent similar issues in the future.
Other Possible Causes
If you’ve ruled out the starter motor and battery but are still experiencing starting issues, several other components could be at fault. Understanding these potential causes can help you diagnose and address the problem more effectively.
Possible Causes:
1 Anti-Theft Immobilizer Issue:
Modern vehicles have anti-theft systems that prevent starting if they detect an issue. A malfunction or miscommunication with the vehicle’s key fob can trigger this system, blocking a start signal.
2 Faulty Ignition Switch:
The ignition switch sends signals to control units which in turn send power to the starter motor. If the switch fails, it might not send the start signal, leading to starting issues.
3 Relay Issues: Starter relays control the power flow to the starter motor. A faulty relay can prevent the starter motor from receiving the necessary current, leading to starting problems.
4 Clutch Pedal: For manual transmission vehicles, the clutch pedal switch ensures that the clutch is fully depressed before starting. A faulty switch can prevent the car from starting.
5 Faulty Park Neutral Safety Switch (Automatic Transmissions): In automatic vehicles, the park neutral safety switch prevents starting unless the transmission is in ‘Park’ or ‘Neutral.’ A malfunctioning switch can block the start signal.
Place the vehicle in “N” and crank the engine; if the engine now starts, a faulty switch is the issue.
Quick Tip:
If you suspect any of these components might be causing your starting issues, check the related fuses and wiring connections. The park neutral switch is attached to the transmission where the shift lever selector connects to it. Checking all the simple stuff first makes sense. Consult your vehicle’s manual or seek professional help to diagnose and repair these components if necessary.
Pro Tip:
Sometimes, a simple reset of the anti-theft system solves the problem. Lock the vehicle and leave it locked for five minutes before unlocking and trying again.
Sum up
Diagnosing starting issues can be complex, but understanding the signs of a failing starter motor and knowing how to check related components can make it much easier. From the engine not cranking to unusual noises and other potential causes, identifying the problem early can save you time and money on repairs.
Summary of Key Points:
- Engine Doesn’t Crank: Indicates a potential failure of the starter motor or an issue with electrical connections.
- Single Click Sound: Often points to a faulty starter solenoid.
- Repeated Clicking Sound: Often indicates a low battery or loose battery terminals.
- Intermittent Starting Issues: This could be due to a failing starter motor or affected by environmental conditions.
- Grinding Noise: Usually signifies worn gears or misalignment between the starter motor and flywheel.
- No Sound at All: This may suggest a faulty starter motor, ignition switch, or electrical components.
- Smoke or Burning Smell: Indicates overheating or internal failure of the starter motor.
- Other Possible Causes: Issues with the anti-theft system, ignition switch, relays, clutch pedal switch, or neutral safety switch are also possible.
If you’re experiencing any of these issues, start by checking the battery and connections, then proceed to inspect the starter motor and related components. Consulting a professional mechanic is always a good option for complex problems or if you’re unsure about the diagnosis.
- About the Author
- Latest Posts
John Cunningham is an Automotive Technician and writer on Rustyautos.com. He’s been a mechanic for over twenty-five years and has worked for GM, Volvo, Volkswagen, Land Rover, and Jaguar dealerships.
John uses his know-how and experience to write articles that help fellow gearheads with all aspects of vehicle ownership, including maintenance, repair, and troubleshooting.