The Warning Light That Lied: When a Loose Terminal Triggers an Oil Pressure Panic

There are two kinds of dashboard warnings. The ones you ignore until your next coffee stop, and the ones that make your stomach drop.

The low oil pressure warning is firmly in the second camp.

So when I was dispatched to an MBR who’d pulled over on the side of a country road—engine off, hazards on—I knew this was serious business. He’d done the right thing. Shut it down the second he saw the warning, didn’t even try to limp it home. Smart.

Because if your oil pressure really is low? That engine is on borrowed time.

First Impressions: No Drama Under the Hood

When I arrived, the engine had cooled down, and I started with the basics. Oil level was spot on. Clean too—no sludge, no sign of a leak. I asked if he’d topped up recently. He hadn’t. He gets it serviced on schedule.

Quick Scan, Suspicious Code

I plugged in the scanner. P0523 – High voltage (open circuit).

Now, some folks would stop here and say, “intermittent bad sensor.” Swap it out, job done. But I’ve seen enough false diagnoses caused by wiring to know better.

Modern engines often use a variable oil pressure sensor, which sends a live voltage signal to the engine control module (ECM). The ECM constantly monitors this signal to track real-time oil pressure.

If the signal wire becomes loose, damaged, or disconnected, the ECM interprets the missing voltage as a fault. Because the circuit is open, voltage appears too high — triggering a P0523 code (Oil Pressure Sensor Circuit High Voltage).

It’s not necessarily high oil pressure, just a signal error. The system is designed to flag anything outside the expected range to protect the engine.

The Drag Test: Underrated and Overlooked

I accessed the oil pressure switch, pulled the connector off the sensor to take a closer look. Nothing corroded, no oil intrusion, no broken wires at a glance. But I’ve been down this road before, and I don’t trust “at a glance.”

So I grabbed a small pick and performed a drag test—basically checking the grip of the connector terminals. You insert the pin and feel the tension. Should be snug. This one? Loose as a goose.

One of the female terminals had poor contact tension. That means it wasn’t gripping the sensor pin tightly, causing intermittent signal loss. When the engine hit certain vibrations or bumps in the road or temperatures, the connection likely dipped just enough to throw a false low-pressure warning.

A Quick Fix and a Word of Caution

I gently tightened the terminal with a pick, just enough to restore proper contact. Reconnected it, cleared the code.

Next, I turned the key; I didn’t expect to hear rattles or knocks, and I didn’t. If pressure were truly low, you would know about it. It doesn’t whisper. It screams.

So far, so good.

Everything behaved. No warning. No codes returned, based on the engine’s behaviour, it was just fine.

I told the MBR:
I’d get that connector repinned or replaced, as tightening the pin is a short-term to medium-term repair.

What Could’ve Happened?

If this guy had kept driving and ignored the light, assuming it was just a glitch, he’d have been lucky.
If he’d panicked and had the car towed and the sensor replaced without testing? Expensive, unnecessary.
Worse still, if it had been real oil pressure loss, and he kept going?

That engine would be scrap.

Top Tip

When your oil light comes on and the engine sounds fine—don’t just trust or dismiss it. Test it.

• Check the oil level first.
• If it’s clean and full, look at the wiring to the pressure sensor.
• Do a drag test on the terminals. Loose fit = unreliable signal.

Your sensor can’t do its job if the wiring is loose.

—Northcap out

👇 Don’t miss this.
Grab Breakdown-Proof Your Car — free tips from 20 years on the roadside.
No fluff. Just the stuff that keeps you out of trouble.